First in a new series featuring attorney Maggie Gallagher, a
former Chicago prosecutor who has returned to her “safer” mid-west hometown of Kerry
(fictional) Ohio, in order to spend more time with her family. As a lawyer who has grown up and practiced in
the Mid-west, I had to suspend a lot of disbelief for the telling of this
story, including the law and the setting. While Kirkland’s story was well
written, I found it to be a bit generic in setting and unreasonably simplistic in
its understanding and portrayal of the law and small-town life.
Maggie happens to see emergency vehicles at a childhood friends’
home while out on a run and stops by.
There has been a shooting. Ultimately,
her friend is charged with a crime connected to it, and ballistics tests show
the gun involved is one used in an unrelated, and unsolved, murder a year and a
half earlier.
Of course, her friend is charged with murder and the case
speeds to trial. The rest of the book is basically narrative of the trial, and
for me, it was about as accurate as any crime drama.
I listened to this book on audio and found the narrator a
bit much. She made Maggie sound like she
was always the victim, and my experience with women lawyers, especially in the
criminal field, is that there may be attempts to victimize them, but those attempts
do not define a mindset.
Other than a couple of backyard barbecues, I found nothing
that marked this book as a Midwest representative. I think it could have stood a little more
research.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher, Relay Publishing for the
review copy. The Midwest Lawyer was published on November 21, 2025.